Ideas to shop around
Directions rather than one particular thing, for when you’d rather choose. Some come with a few that fit.

Stocking Stuffers for Dogs
Treats, chews and toys for dogs of any size. Established names like KONG, Greenies and Benebone are chosen over generic chews because they hold up to heavy chewers and are made with known ingredients.
9 that fit · about $5.28 – $17.94
Full Moon Human Grade Chicken Jerky Dog Treatsabout $17.94 · amazon.com
Pedigree Dentastix Large Breedabout $16.98 · amazon.com
Benebone Wishbone Dog Chewabout $12.78 · amazon.com
Chuckit Medium Tennis Balls 4 Packabout $5.28 · amazon.com
KONG Classic Dog Toy, Mediumabout $11.96 · amazon.com
LUKITO Lick Mat, 2 Packabout $8.99 · amazon.com
Collapsible Dog Bowls, 2 Packabout $6.98 · amazon.com
Greenies Occupy Twists Dog Treats, 12 Countabout $15.98 · amazon.com
heouvo Magnetic Dog Treat Pouch with Clickerabout $9.99 · amazon.com

Stocking Stuffers for Cats
Toys and treats that keep indoor cats busy: wands and lasers for play with the owner, catnip toys for solo play, and lickable treats cats tend to accept.
10 that fit · about $7.97 – $17.97
Temptations MixUps Crunchy Cat Treatsabout $14.98 · amazon.com
Pawaboo Cat Feather Wandabout $8.09 · amazon.com
Yeowww Catnip Banana Toyabout $8.49 · amazon.com
Catnip Pillow Toys 3 Packabout $9.98 · amazon.com
Rechargeable Cat Laser Toyabout $7.97 · amazon.com
SleekEZ Cat Deshedding Brushabout $17.97 · amazon.com
ASPCA Cat Tunnel with Rattle Toyabout $10.24 · amazon.com
Catnip Spray for Catsabout $9.99 · amazon.com
INABA Churu Cat Treatsabout $13.99 · amazon.com
TIMHAKA Cat Scratching Boardabout $8.99 · amazon.com

Pet Parent Stuffers
Practical items for the person holding the leash: walk gear, cleanup tools and holiday decor for the pet, each cheaper and more useful than a pet-themed novelty.
5 that fit · about $5.98 – $15.99
Earth Rated Poop Bag Holder with Bagsabout $5.98 · amazon.com
PetLovers Extra Sticky Lint Roller Value Packabout $12.99 · amazon.com
Pet Christmas Stockings 3 Packabout $15.99 · amazon.com
BLACK+DECKER Pet Hair Remover Rollerabout $13.88 · amazon.com
Kalimdor Dog Water Bottleabout $12.99 · amazon.com

Paws, Grooming and Holiday Stuffers
Small care items and holiday extras for pets: paw balm for winter sidewalks, nail clippers for home grooming and festive accessories for photos.
4 that fit · about $6.99 – $11.99
Paw Balm Jar, 2.5 ozabout $11.99 · amazon.com
Candure Pet Nail Clippersabout $6.99 · amazon.com
Holiday Dog Bandanas, 9 Packabout $8.99 · amazon.com
Happy Pawlidays Dog Photo Ornamentabout $9.99 · amazon.com